Introduction
Secondhand clothing has moved from niche to mainstream, but myths about resale still swirl. At The Resell Club — the most sustainable thrift company on the planet and climate change certified — we see the same concerns from shoppers and sellers. Below we separate common myths from facts, explain what they mean for you, and share practical tips for shopping and consigning clothing that extends garments' lives and reduces waste.
Top resale myths vs facts
Myth 1: Resale clothing is low quality or damaged.
Fact: Many resale pieces are like-new, designer, or gently worn items that have plenty of life left. Professional resale companies grade and quality-check items so buyers know what to expect. The Resell Club uses technology-driven processes to vet inventory and present accurate descriptions and photos.
Tip: Look for detailed photos, condition notes, brand information, and return policies (we offer free shipping and free returns). If you’re unsure, ask the seller for more photos or measurements before buying.
Myth 2: Secondhand is unhygienic.
Fact: Clothing can be safely cleaned. Professional resellers often launder, steam, or professionally clean items before listing. At home, most garments can be washed or sanitized per care labels; delicate items can be steam-treated or dry-cleaned.
Tip: Check care instructions and factor potential cleaning into the item’s value. If a listing notes professional cleaning, that’s a good sign the seller takes hygiene seriously.
Myth 3: Resale is only for bargain hunters — you can’t find quality or trendy pieces.
Fact: Resale covers all price points and styles. You’ll find everyday basics, vintage finds, designer items, and current-season pieces. Many shoppers buy resale specifically to access higher-quality brands at a fraction of original prices.
Tip: Use filters and saved searches to track brands, sizes, and styles you love. Treat resale like curated shopping — patience and persistence pay off.
Myth 4: Selling is complicated and not worth the money.
Fact: Selling can be straightforward and financially rewarding, especially when you work with a transparent, reputable service. The Resell Club provides clear consignment payout structures so you can understand potential earnings before you consign. Check our consignment payout percentages for details.
Tip: Read the terms, choose the right platform for your item type, and invest a little time in presentation (good photos and honest descriptions). That will maximize interest and payouts.
Myth 5: Resale shopping is risky because sizes are inconsistent.
Fact: Size variability exists across brands and eras, but good sellers provide measurements and fit notes. Many resale platforms standardize sizing information to reduce confusion.
Tip: Always check listed measurements (bust, waist, length) and compare them to a garment you own that fits well. If measurements aren’t provided, request them before purchasing.
Myth 6: Resale isn't actually sustainable.
Fact: Reusing clothing extends garment life, reduces demand for new production, and lowers overall environmental impact. The Resell Club is committed to measurable sustainability: we’re climate change certified, a 1% for the Planet member, ocean positive, and we use recyclable, recycled, and compostable shipping materials. You can read more about our work on our our sustainability impact page.
Tip: Choose resellers that disclose sustainability practices and track impact. Buying pre-owned is one of the most effective ways individuals can reduce fashion’s footprint.
Myth 7: You can’t resell everything — only designer or brand-name items sell.
Fact: While designer pieces often hold resale value, many everyday brands and basics sell well too. Demand varies by season, trend, and category. If you’re curious which items we accept, check our what we accept page to see typical categories and condition requirements.
Tip: Clean and repair items when possible, present honest descriptions, and understand seasonality. Basics and well-made staples can be surprisingly popular.
How to shop and sell smarter: practical checklist
- Check condition and measurements: Look beyond size tags and inspect photos/notes.
- Ask questions: Message sellers about wear, repairs, or provenance before buying.
- Factor in returns: Free returns make trying secondhand safer — The Resell Club offers free shipping and free returns on our website.
- Price and payout transparency: If selling, compare consignment payout schedules so you understand earnings (consignment payout percentages).
- Support sustainable systems: Prefer resellers with verified sustainability claims and circular practices.
Why resale matters
Every piece that gets reused reduces the need for new production, saves resources, and keeps textiles out of landfills and oceans. Since 2015, The Resell Club has used technology to change the way resale is done while maintaining a deep commitment to sustainability and transparency. Being the most sustainable thrift company on the planet isn’t just a label — it’s a practice reflected in our operations, certifications, and materials.
Final thought
Don’t let myths stop you from enjoying the benefits of resale. Whether you’re buying or selling, a little knowledge helps you make better choices for your wardrobe and the planet. If you have questions about consigning, payouts, or accepted items, visit our what we accept page or check consignment payout percentages. For anything else, our team is happy to help — see our contact us page to get in touch.